October 29, 2026
Can AI Value Your Commercial Property in Montana? We Put It to the Test
October 29, 2026
Short answer: not reliably. Montana is a non-disclosure state, so real estate sale prices aren't public. AI tools can only guess from asking prices, market averages and whatever public data they can find. When we ran a Bozeman building we know inside out through Google Gemini and Claude, the two tools landed $1.38 million apart. Neither one got the square footage right.
If you're making a real decision, like a sale, a refinance, a buyout or a divorce settlement, you need a value built on closed sales and your property's actual numbers.
This week I met with a client going through a divorce. They needed a broker price opinion on a commercial property they own together, so one spouse could buy the other out.
Partway through, they mentioned something that stopped me. Their mediator had suggested they just have AI run a valuation.
I get why. It's fast, it's free, and it sounds objective. But in Montana, it's a shortcut that can steer you wrong, and in a divorce, the number you anchor to matters.
I'm glad they called before they relied on it. Their AI valuation came in about $100,000 above the fair market value we arrived at using the property's actual expenses, financials, lease rates and closed comparable sales.
In a buyout, one spouse pays the other for their share of the property. If the property is overvalued, the buyer pays for value that isn't there. On an even split, a $100,000 overvaluation means the buying spouse overpays by about $50,000, and that's money they won't get back when they eventually sell.
Here's what we think pushed their AI number too high:
No closed sales. It couldn't see what similar buildings actually sold for.
Newer comps. It compared their building to newer, more modern properties that command higher prices.
The wrong kind of property. One of its comps was a restaurant, a completely different use from their building.
Any one of those can skew a valuation. Together, they're why you want a person who knows the local market behind the number.
It means the price a property actually sold for is not public record. Every Montana sale is reported to the Department of Revenue on a Realty Transfer Certificate, but state law keeps that sale information confidential and for official use only (MCA 15-7-308).
So where does real sale data live? In the MLS. As licensed brokers, we have access to actual closed prices and use them for evaluations and internal analysis. An AI tool scraping the internet doesn't.
That gap is the whole story. Without closed sales, AI is valuing your property off asking prices and averages, and asking prices are what a seller hopes for, not what a buyer paid.
We wanted to see how AI would do on a property where we already know the answer.
We picked a commercial building near Four Corners that Mike McKenna helped redevelop and is part owner of. We've been involved since the redevelopment, we know its full history, and we run evaluations on it regularly.
Here's how we set it up:
Why no rent roll? Because that's how most owners would actually use AI: type in an address and ask what it's worth. With real income data, both tools would do better. We wanted to see what they could do on their own.
Gemini gave a fair market value range of $6,980,000 to $9,074,000. That's a $2.1 million spread, about 30% from bottom to top.
A range that wide doesn't help anyone set a realistic expectation. In a divorce, a sale or a buyout, it's a recipe for two people anchoring to opposite ends.
Here's where it fell short:
Claude gave a tighter range of $5,000,000 to $5,600,000, based on seven comparable buildings it found in the Bozeman and Belgrade market. In our opinion, that's lower than where we'd list the property.
Claude noted that Montana sale prices aren't public and that its seven comps were asking prices, not closed sales. It adjusted them for size, age, location and land. For example, it cut comps under about 13,000 SF by 7.5% to 10%, since smaller buildings tend to sell for more per square foot.
Here's where it fell short:
It relied on asking prices. Asking prices are what sellers hope for, not what buyers paid.
It had the building size wrong.
It ignored condition. Nothing in the evaluation reflected the building's condition.
It missed the extra land. It ran a land value check, but it didn't account for the property's developable acreage.
It skipped the income approach. The building has leases in place, but Claude didn't use income to cross-check its comps.
The two AI tools didn't even overlap. Gemini's low end was $1.38 million above Claude's high end.
Google Gemini | Claude | Local broker (MLS access) | |
Value range | $6.98M to $9.07M | $5.0M to $5.6M | Single, defensible opinion of value |
Spread | About $2.1M (30%) | About $600K (12%) | Narrow, backed by closed sales |
Comps used | Market averages | 7 asking prices, adjusted | Actual closed sale prices |
Income approach | Yes, on estimated income | No | Yes, on the actual rent roll |
Lease structure (gross vs. NNN) | Unknown | Unknown | Known |
Square footage | Wrong | Wrong | Verified |
Developable land | Missed | Missed | Valued |
Building condition | Not considered | Not considered | Inspected in person |
AI can only value what it can see. In Montana, the most important inputs are the ones it can't.
Closed sale prices. Real comps live in the MLS, not on the open web.
The actual rent roll. Real income beats estimated income every time.
Gross vs. NNN. Under a gross lease the landlord pays operating costs. Under NNN the tenant pays taxes, insurance and maintenance. Same rent, very different net income.
Condition. A new roof or a deferred maintenance list moves value, and neither shows up in an average.
Hidden upside. Developable land, expansion potential or a below-market lease rolling soon.
Accurate building data. Both tools got the square footage wrong, and every per-square-foot number built on that is off too.
What's happening right now. We see the deals, the pricing conversations and the buyer demand in Bozeman every week. AI is working off whatever it last found online.
Not for this. AI can help you get familiar with terms like cap rate or NNN before a conversation. It can't tell you what your building is worth in Montana.
It can't see closed sales, it doesn't know your leases, and it can't walk the building. For anything with real money or a legal outcome riding on it, get a number from someone who can.
A broker price opinion (BPO) is a licensed broker's opinion of what a property would likely sell for, based on closed sales, income and local market knowledge. It's faster and less expensive than an appraisal, and it's a smart first step for owners weighing a sale, a buyout or a settlement.
A certified appraisal is done by a licensed appraiser to formal standards. Lenders, courts and some legal agreements require one. If you're not sure which you need, ask your attorney or mediator. A BPO is never a substitute for an appraisal when an appraisal is required. You can verify an appraiser's license through the Montana Board of Real Estate Appraisers.
Not on its own. Montana is a non-disclosure state, so AI can't see actual sale prices. In our test, Gemini and Claude valued the same Bozeman building $1.38 million apart.
No. Sale prices reported on Montana's Realty Transfer Certificate are confidential under state law. Licensed brokers can see closed prices through the MLS.
Start with a broker price opinion from a local commercial broker with MLS access. It should be based on closed comparable sales, your actual rent roll and lease structure, and the building's condition.
Under a gross lease, the landlord pays the building's operating costs. Under an NNN (triple net) lease, the tenant pays property taxes, insurance and maintenance on top of rent. The difference changes net income and the property's value.
No. A BPO is a broker's opinion of likely sale price. An appraisal is a formal valuation by a licensed appraiser, and it's required for most loans and many legal proceedings.
If you or someone you know needs to understand what a commercial property is actually worth, DM us or contact our team. We'll pull the closed sales, look at your leases and give you a number you can make decisions with.